The Actual Return on Investment (ROI) of Hiring a Professional Bookkeeper vs. Hiring an Employee

Short answer: hiring a bookkeeping firm in the Chesterfield area usually costs about $240 to $540 a month for six hours of work, and P&L Business Solutions plans start at $400 a month. Hiring an employee can look cheaper on paper, but payroll costs, benefits and turnover change the math. Here is how the two compare.

Do you know the cost of bookkeeping in Chesterfield VA?  Let’s walk through some thoughts on how to objectively look at the situation and assess the return on investment that outsourcing your accounting/bookkeeping provides. So, how much does bookkeeping cost for most small businesses assuming you need only six hours of bookkeeping per month?

Hiring a Bookkeeper/Accountant:

Cost:

  • Most bookkeeping firms charge $40-$90 per hour
  • Average cost of bookkeeping in Chesterfield VA is between $240-$540 per month based on 6 hours per month of bookkeeping services

Pros:

  • The bookkeeping firm will have a vested interest in doing a good job for that is their livelihood and they will not want to jeopardize it.
  • You will have easy access to your financial records to give you up-to-date insight into the financial viability of your business venture at the touch of your fingertips.
  • They provide quality assurance and accuracy.
  • They are certified in the bookkeeping software and can resolve any issues that may come up in the software.
  • Having accurate and up-to-date books will cut down the time it will take a tax accountant/CPA/Enrolled Agent to do your taxes which will you save you money, time, and stress at tax time.
  • They can provide expert financial/business advice to help in the profitability of your business.

Cons:

  • May cost a little more than hiring an employee or it may not; however, with the lower cost, comes greater risks as mentioned below.

Hiring “Someone on the Side” or Using the Office Admin to Do the Bookkeeping:

Cost:

  • The median pay for bookkeeping, accounting, and auditing clerks was $24.36 per hour in May 2025.¹ At six hours a month, that is about $146 in wages. Wages made up about 70% of employer compensation costs for private industry workers in June 2026,² so the fully loaded cost is closer to $209 a month. That is arithmetic on national averages, not a quote. You would also pay for office equipment and the cost of hiring.

Pros:

  • May be less expensive or may cost the same or more depending on what other employee costs you would have.

Cons:

  • How long will the person stay in the position? If not very long, your costs will be greater because you will then have to advertise or pay a temporary service in order to find another employee. You would also have some amount of training for the new employee which costs time which costs additional funds.
  • How would you validate their credentials and accuracy of their bookkeeping skills? Perhaps this is just a side gig for them and maybe they “just don’t know what they don’t know.” Mistakes could cost a lot of money down the road.
  • Will they just be a “Yes Man (or Woman)” and not give the business owner good accounting advice?
  • Do they have the commitment to help your business succeed for the long-haul on your road ahead?
  • It is a known fact that most fraud in small businesses is done by the “internal” office manager/bookkeeper/family member of the business owner. The more “hats” the internal employee doing the books “wears,” the more likely it is for fraud not to be detected until it is too late and the business experiences a financial setback that it may not be able to recover from.

Want the full comparison? Read outsourced accounting vs. hiring in-house. To see what each plan includes, visit our bookkeeping pricing and bookkeeping services pages. If you run a contracting business, read bookkeeping for contractors.

Sources

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks,” Occupational Outlook Handbook. bls.gov
  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026” (private industry workers). bls.gov